davedraper.com home

First Things First

Before you get distracted by all the great options you're about to find here, please sign up for Dave's free weekly newsletter so he can continue to encourage and motivate you toward your fitness goals.
Enter your email address here:
Chris M writes:
"You blend plain-spoken wisdom, motivational fire and wry humor into a weekly email jolt that leaves me itching to hit the gym. Whether I'm looking for workout routines, diet tips or a friendly kick in the butt, the Bomber comes through every time." ... Read more...

Sciatica

I began my funky attempts at fitness in the late ‘70s, at the outset of the jogging craze (trudging is what I was doing), and from then until fairly recently, we fitness enthusiasts spread the rumor that sciatica was a runner’s problem, and bent-leg situps were the cure. Now that we’re past those ridiculous decades, we now know that’s not the case, neither the cause of the problem, nor the cure.

In fact, sciatica isn’t a diagnosis at all; it’s a symptom, and it means pain down the leg. If you went to a doctor or chiropractor and got that diagnosis, and the instructions were to rest or to take an anti-inflammatory — and was the extent of the instructions, nothing more — it’s time to get a new doc. Sometimes the inflammation will run its course and the pain will dissipate, but it won’t be from following those instructions, and it’s likely to flare up again in a few months if you don’t get to the underlying cause.

What’s happening is there is a nerve or perhaps nerves under pressure, sending pain running from the spine down the back of the legs, usually one leg, but  possibly both. Somehow, you have to figure out what’s causing the pressure: Is it at a disc, either inflammation or possibly a rupture or herniation, or perhaps the common reason of something pressing on the sciatic nerve as it travels through the glute region?

In Dave’s case, which you may remember from his back surgery a couple of summers ago, it was from severely degenerated discs. The surgery took the pressure off the nerves and the pain is gone, but that was one situation where holding off on surgery backfired; the nerves were damaged enough they were unable to repair — reinnervate is what that’s called — and he lost a bit of lower leg function.

The moral of Dave’s story is this: If the pain doesn’t change after a month, pursue specialized doctoring. I don’t mean to say you should get surgery if you have back pain for a month, but if there’s no change in symptoms after doing the techniques that follow, don’t be too stubborn to get help.

After having watched Dave’s process, I’d first try a neurologist to check for peripheral artery disease (PAD), and then I wouldn’t wait too terribly long before queuing up at the neurosurgeon’s for a MRI and possibly even surgery if the diagnosis was degenerative disc disease. If the diagnosis was PAD, I’d seriously consider EDTA IV chelation, which Dave did and which didn’t work, but that could be because he didn’t have PAD but wanted to avoid back surgery so he tried it anyway. Along the way, I’d start paying attention to cardiovascular issues, too, because PAD is unlikely to stand alone; those other arteries are probably getting into the action, or out of it, I guess is a better description.

If you make your way to a physical therapist or a chiropractor, look less for manipulation and more for soft tissue therapies to take down the inflammation. You might get some radiant heat, followed by a STIM treatment, which will probably give you some temporary relief. Once home, icing the low spine and glutes a couple of times a day will help. Those reusable fishermen ice sheets are real handy for chilling the whole back at once.

Let’s assume the pain isn’t debilitating and you’ve decided to forage around for answers on your own for a bit. Here are the easiest things to try:

Using a tennis ball, look for a trigger point in the piriformis
You need to a flashplayer enabled browser to view this YouTube video

Now the next one could be a little controversial: McKenzie back extensions. The main reason for the hesitation is because if there’s a disc herniation, there’s a chance it could be an unusual bulge and the extension could make it worse. But the thing is, if you ease your way into these, should there be a problem, you’ll know it long before you can cause any trouble.

And I figure, if you’ve got back or sciatic pain, you’re not jumping whole-hog into any back exercises anyway, so I feel safe in throwing this out there. I have a good friend from the gym who had terrible back problems, was sidelined at his aggressive construction work, had a bunch of injections and was heading toward surgery. He started doing the McKenzie exercises, quickly left the medical funnel and has been doing great ever since. Now there’s a guy who’d be disappointed in me if I’m too chicken to write about press-ups in a bit about back pain. Here’s how, with an explanation from physical therapist, Dr. Mike Jones.

Practice back extensions using the McKenzie Press-up
You need to a flashplayer enabled browser to view this YouTube video

Now some exercises. Start here: Cook Hip Lift for glute activation, to overcome too much sitting
You need to a flashplayer enabled browser to view this YouTube video

Abduction exercises to strengthen the outside of the leg, offsetting too much front-to back action
You need to a flashplayer enabled browser to view this YouTube video

If you had little success with your corrective work and are enjoying a bit of relief, it’s time to address the cause. Why did this happen in the first place? The most likely cause is a problem between the low back and the hips, and the easiest place to start is a hip mobility program. When the hips aren’t moving well, the low back moves too much, and that will get you into trouble. For most adults sitting at a desk reading this, if you aren’t working mobility, you’re probably losing it, and if your back isn’t hurting now, it will be. Here’s how to get started on a hip mobility program.

I leave you with two more suggestions. First, hop on over to Esther Gokhale’s site and order her book, 8 Steps to a Pain-Free Back, in which she’ll explain and demonstrate our faulty postures and what to do about them. While you’re waiting for the book to arrive (which you’ll faithfully read and practice instead of burying it under the TV stand), settle in for this one-hour video.

You need to a flashplayer enabled browser to view this YouTube video


9 Responses to 'Sciatica'

Subscribe to comments with RSS or TrackBack to 'Sciatica'.


  1. on February 10th, 2010 at 8:39 pm

    I’ve found sciatic pain is often the result of a rotated pelvis. This happens when the muscles in front of the pelvis asymmetrically pull one side of the pelvis forward. This creates unilateral spinal extension and can pinch the nerve roots composing the sciatic nerve. This is correctable with exercise but the other big problem is that movement habits are reinforcing these issues. A couple of examples of habits that may be perpetuating sciatic pain are standing or working asymmetrically putting more weight on one leg than the other. This leads to the asymmetries in the muscle tightness. Typically, sciatic pain responds relatively quickly to corrections on both fronts. I’ve just written a book about fixing back and sciatic pain using an approach that has been very effective over the last few years. Thank you for your article.


  2. on June 22nd, 2010 at 11:32 pm

    Sciatic pain is ofter rotated pelvis. This happens when you are playing and muscles in front of the pelvis pull one site to other side or forward. This leads to the asymmetries in the muscle tightness. nice article thanks for sharing your knowledge.


  3. on July 31st, 2010 at 12:16 pm

    This is a good article – thanks for posting it! I never thought of using those re-usable fisherman ice sheets for my clients. Way to think outside the box!
    I also recommend using a 4″ kids ball instead of tennis ball to massage your Piriformis muscle. Most people find the tennis ball too hard. I sell a nice little pckg. of 2 balls on my site that work well. http://bit.ly/sciaticarelief

  4. JAD said,

    on October 2nd, 2010 at 1:58 pm

    I suffer from back pain periodically. My problems are acute and I exercise periodically to strengthen the muscles. Surgery has several dangers. It sometimes best to see if the problem can be overcome without surgery. I agree that exercising is best. I had some trouble seeing videos.


  5. on October 7th, 2010 at 7:19 pm

    I recently experienced the pain of piriformis syndrome and stretching helped a great deal. Curious that when talking about a cause few seem to go beyond a physical cause in the body. From my experiences with running and pain, I have learned to examine my shoes, behavior including sleeping habits, physical conditioning, and finally whatever else is in my environment. More often than not, my shoes or a new behavior is the underlying problem.

  6. Alex said,

    on November 10th, 2010 at 9:17 am

    I’ve often found sciatic pain be the cause of uneven muscle strength that in time has pushed the backbone and made a nerve be under pressure. Stretches help in regaining balance and clearing the problem.
    Thank you for the wonderful videos!


  7. on January 31st, 2011 at 6:48 am

    I use this piriformis stretch with patients all the time…i also use the mcKenzie method for disc herniations. Very cool videos!


  8. on February 10th, 2011 at 10:09 am

    Almost anyone having sciatica will benefit from gentle stretching of the piriformis-especially first thing in the morning. Morning is also a great time to use cold packs to the back. Being careful the first hour of the day and not getting the back and sciatic nerve stirred up can make the rest of the day much better.

  9. Bob said,

    on April 23rd, 2011 at 3:42 am

    A good well informed article to a very painful condition
    Back pain is becoming something of normality in today’s society as our lifestyle dictates, and in some cases with dire consequences leaving an individual completely helpless. Work pressure and the onset of increasing age have a part to play in this problem area.
    Sciatica plays a major role in this problem and often ignored through lack of understanding and willingness accept there is an underlying problem.
    The term sciatica is a general term that is used for lower back pain. This can be felt in not only in the lower back but in the buttocks and or various parts of the leg and foot Seeking the correct treatment for sciatic pain is important as sciatica is a symptom of a cause which is irritating the sciatic nerve.
    Because sciatica symptoms will very often be somewhat different the exact treatment will depend on the underlying cause. Old injuries from sports or accidents can manifest the onset of sciatica and age has no bearing on this.
    Piriformis Syndrome is often related to sports injuries or overusing the muscle in one direction and strangling the sciatic nerve beneath it.

Post a comment